5/17/2017 DRAFT
This is a list of suggested Enduring Issues which is not intended to be memorized. It is
not meant to be an all-inclusive or comprehensive list.
Part III Enduring Issues
Considerations
• An enduring issue is a challenge or problem that a society has faced and debated or
discussed across time. An enduring issue is one that many societies have attempted to
address with varying degrees of success.
• Enduring Issues are often nested, e.g., conflict (war, competition, armed struggle,
resistance, invasions, threats to balance of power) and human rights violations (injustice,
inequality, discrimination, unfair treatment, persecution for beliefs, threats to cultural
identity, restrictions to movement). These sets of issues show a range of possible issues a
student could identify when writing the Enduring Issues Essay. Issues can be expressed
negatively as well as positively.
• The concept of “Nested Issues” is one way to think about Enduring Issues. When
choosing the Enduring Issue to write about, a student may choose one of the Enduring
Issues identified in this chart, a nested issue, or one of their own issues. What presents
itself as a “Nested Issue” in one set of documents could be the Enduring Issue in another
set of documents depending on the documents provided and the student’s perspective.
• To identify an Enduring Issue a student must analyze each of the documents, determine
the issues in each document, and then group those issues under a common category that
encompasses all of these other issues. This common category is the student’s Enduring
Issue. An example using the Prototype Enduring Issue Essay might be human rights
violations or injustice: Doc. 1 discrimination, Doc. 2 destruction of a group, Doc. 3
genocide, Doc. 4 apartheid, Doc. 5 religious discrimination. The issues from these
documents fit under the category of human rights violations or injustice.
• The identified Enduring Issue must be an issue that has affected people or has been
affected by people and has continued to be an issue across time or has changed over time.
• Defining the Enduring Issue will require information from the documents and the
application of social studies knowledge.
• The identification of the Enduring Issue will be dependent on the documents provided,
the context of those documents, and the perspective or lens the student uses to interpret
those documents. This set of circumstances will affect how the Enduring Issue is defined.
1
5/17/2017 DRAFT
This is a list of suggested Enduring Issues which is not intended to be memorized. It is
not meant to be an all-inclusive or comprehensive list.
Enduring Issue
Nested Issues
Grade 10
Key Idea
Connections
Grade 9
Key Idea
Connections
Conflict
war, competition, armed struggle,
10.1, 10.2,
9.2, 9.3, 9.4,
resistance, invasions, threats to balance of
10.3, 10.4,
9.5, 9.6, 9.7,
power, power struggles, disputes over
10.5, 10.6,
9.8, 9.9, 9.10
boundaries or location of boundaries,
10.7, 10.8,
disputes over land use, disputes over land
acquisition, disputes over resources,
disputes over resource use, disputes over
waste disposal sites, disputes over socio-
economic status, disputes over who has
power, disputes over how power is
obtained, disputes over how power is
maintained, ethnic disputes, religious
disputes, disputes between social classes,
terrorism; debates over choice of reform
needed, negative reaction to reform;
response to lack of reform
10.9, 10.10
Human Rights
injustice, inequality, discrimination,
10.2, 10.3,
9.4, 9.6, 9.9,
Violations
exclusion, unfair treatment, cruel treatment,
10.4, 10.5,
9.10
persecution for beliefs, threats to cultural
10.6,10.7,
identity, restrictions to movement,
10.8, 10.9,
enslavement, human trafficking,
disenfranchisement, lack of freedom of
speech, lack of freedom of assembly, lack
of freedom of press, censorship, genocide,
denied access to earning a living
10.10
Scarcity
lack of food, lack of human resources, lack
10.2, 10.3,
9.1, 9.4, 9.8,
of natural resources, lack of industrial
10.4, 10.5,
9.10
resources, lack of housing/shelter, lack of
10.7, 10.8,
clean water/water resources, lack of medical
treatment, lack of arable land, lack of
technology, lack of capital
10.9, 10.10
Power
lack of access to power, unfair distribution
10.1, 10.2,
9.1, 9.3, 9.4,
of power, shifts in power and authority,
10.3, 10.4,
9.5, 9.6, 9.7,
power struggles, relationship of ruler to
10.5, 10.6,
9.8, 9.9, 9.10
ruled, social class tensions, ability of the
10.7, 10.8,
people to have a voice in government
(consent of the governed/social contract),
shifts in the balance of power, access to free
and fair elections, lack of free and fair
elections
10.9, 10.10
2
5/17/2017 DRAFT
This is a list of suggested Enduring Issues which is not intended to be memorized. It is
not meant to be an all-inclusive or comprehensive list.
Enduring Issue
Nested Issues
Grade 10
Key Idea
Connections
Grade 9
Key Idea
Connections
Security
threats to privacy, threats to property,
10.1, 10.2,
9.3, 9.4, 9.5,
terrorism, lack of safety, nuclear
10.3, 10.4,
9.7, 9.8, 9.9,
proliferation, biological weapons, chemical
10.5, 10.6,
9.10
weapons, weapons of mass destruction,
10.7, 10.8,
impact of new weaponry, role of technology
in protecting security, role of technology in
harming security, hacking, cyber theft,
crime, debates over piracy, debates over
espionage, need for espionage, protection of
borders/frontiers, protection of national
sovereignty, debate over formation of
alliances/membership in an alliance, debate
over the need for collective security,
responsibilities of collective security,
protection from disease
10.9, 10.10
Population
strain on resources, strain on housing,
10.1, 10.3,
9.1, 9.6, 9.8,
Growth
increase in production of waste and need to
10.4, 10.5,
9.10
address waste disposal, sanitation
10.7, 10.8,
conditions/strain on sanitation systems,
healthcare needs, ability to feed population,
expanding the need to educate the
population, need for social services, debate
over population policies, restrictions on
population growth, impact of negative
population growth, relationship between
population growth and national power, rate
of expansion
10.9, 10.10
3
5/17/2017 DRAFT
This is a list of suggested Enduring Issues which is not intended to be memorized. It is
not meant to be an all-inclusive or comprehensive list.
Enduring Issue
Nested Issues
Grade 10
Key Idea
Connections
Grade 9
Key Idea
Connections
Human Impact on
consequences of establishing
10.1, 10.2,
9.1, 9.2, 9.3,
the Environment
political/physical boundaries, impact of
10.3, 10.4,
9.5, 9.7, 9.8,
boundaries on people, environmental
10.5, 10.6,
9.9, 9.10
degradation, deforestation, desertification,
10.7, 10.8,
global warming, destruction of ozone layer,
pollution, extinction of species/loss of
species, loss of biodiversity, debate over
monoculture, land-use disputes, erosion,
diversion of rivers/water sources, draining
of aquifers, impact of extraction of
resources, use of alternative energy sources,
impact of reducing energy use,
consequences of building road
systems/transportation systems,
consequences of changing agricultural
practices/techniques (use of pesticides, use
of chemical fertilizers, hybrid
seeds/genetically modifying seeds, crop
rotation, irrigation, increasing acreage in
production), impact of changes to the
physical environment/landscape, impact of
policies to adapt to potential flooding,
impact of policies on sustainability, impact
of over-mining, spread of disease
10.9
Impact of
impact of natural physical barriers, impact
10.1, 10.2,
9.1, 9.3, 9.4,
Environment on
of access to plains, impact of access to
10.3, 10.4,
9.9, 9.10
Humans
oceans, impact of access to rivers, impact of
10.5, 10.6,
access to seas, impact of access to straits,
impact of access to lakes, impact of natural
resources, impact of access to fertile soil,
impact of access to fresh water, impact of
physical geography, impact of climate,
impact of weather, impact of natural
disasters, impact of flooding, impact of
earthquake destruction, impact of volcanic
eruptions, impact of destruction by
tsunamis, impact of hurricane/cyclone
destruction, impact of environmental
hazards (collapse of structures, wildfires),
impact of efforts to mitigate natural
disasters, impact of policies designed to
deal with natural disasters
10.7, 10.9
4
5/17/2017 DRAFT
This is a list of suggested Enduring Issues which is not intended to be memorized. It is
not meant to be an all-inclusive or comprehensive list.
Enduring Issue
Nested Issues
Grade 10
Key Idea
Connections
Grade 9
Key Idea
Connections
Tensions Between
loss of cultural identity, loss of language,
10.2, 10.3,
Traditional
loss of traditional beliefs, traditional gender
10.4, 10.5,
Culture and
roles versus modern gender roles, disputes
10.7, 10.8,
Modernization
over gender roles, role of ethnic identity and
power, ethnic tensions, religious identity,
tensions between religious identity and
modernization efforts, debate over
definition of modernization, debate over
westernization as modernization, difficulty
of maintaining traditions in a time of change
10.10
Impact of Trade
integration of new ideas, rejection of new
10.1, 10.2,
9.3, 9.4, 9.5.
ideas, economic sanctions, boycotts,
10.3, 10.4,
9.6, 9.7, 9.8,
embargoes, imposing/levying tariffs, loss of
10.6, 10.7,
9.10
jobs, integration of new technology,
rejection of new technology, introduction of
new goods, rejection of new goods,
distribution of/access to new goods, loss of
cultural identity, loss of language, loss of
traditional beliefs, consequences of
connections, impact of consumption, impact
on raising standards of living, impact of
changes in production, impact of uneven
patterns of development, impact on levels of
poverty, economic costs, economic benefits,
impact of market forces, political benefits,
political costs, social benefits, social costs,
difficulty of maintaining traditions, attempts
to expand trade, attempts to restrict trade;
impact of trade agreements, balance of
trade, impact on environment, ability to
participate in global trade, spread of disease
10.9, 10.10
5
5/17/2017 DRAFT
This is a list of suggested Enduring Issues which is not intended to be memorized. It is
not meant to be an all-inclusive or comprehensive list.
Enduring Issue
Nested Issues
Grade 10
Key Idea
Connections
Grade 9
Key Idea
Connections
Impact of Cultural
loss of/threats to cultural identity, loss
10.1, 10.2,
9.2, 9.3, 9.4,
Diffusion
of/threats to unique language(s), loss of
10.3, 10.4,
9.5, 9.6, 9.7,
traditional beliefs, spread of disease, impact
10.6, 10.7,
9.8, 9.9, 9.10
of introduction of new species
(invasive/noninvasive), conflict, debate over
change, challenge of imported technology,
debate over value of accepting a new good,
debate over value of accepting a new idea,
debate over value of accepting a new
philosophy, debate over value of accepting
a new religion, debate over the pace of
change, benefits of improved transportation,
challenges of improved transportation,
benefits of improved communication,
challenges of improved communication,
benefits of new ideas, unintended
consequences of embracing new ideas,
unintended consequences of embracing new
philosophies, unintended consequences of
accepting new goods, debate over whether
the acceptance of a new good or idea
strengthens or weakens a culture
10.9
Impact of
consequences of technology use for people,
10.1, 10.2,
9.1, 9.3, 9.4,
Technology
consequences of technology use for the
10.3, 10.4,
9.5, 9.8, 9.9,
environment, disruptive nature of
10.5, 10.6,
9.10
technology, impact of technology on
10.7, 10.8,
jobs/livelihoods, environmental costs of
adopting technology, environmental costs of
rejecting technology, production of waste
by new technology, safe waste
disposal/need to address waste disposal
produced by technology, consequence of the
spread of technology on a culture, impact of
technology on physical environment, impact
of technology on cultural traditions, impact
of technology on land usage, impact of
technology on settlement patterns, impact of
technology on settling
disputes/conflicts/warfare, impact of
technology on industrialization, impact of
technology on urbanization, impact on
privacy
10.9, 10.10
6
5/17/2017 DRAFT
This is a list of suggested Enduring Issues which is not intended to be memorized. It is
not meant to be an all-inclusive or comprehensive list.
Enduring Issue
Nested Issues
Grade 10
Key Idea
Connections
Grade 9
Key Idea
Connections
Impact of
low wages, poor working conditions, unsafe
10.3, 10.4,
Industrialization
working conditions, use of child labor,
10.5, 10.6,
unequal wages for similar work, need for
10.7, 10.8,
regulations, need for reform, unionization,
pollution, carbon emissions, consequences
of industrialization, outsourcing jobs,
demand for resources, demand for water,
demand for energy, demand for
transportation, demand for infrastructure,
impact of industrialization on agriculture,
increase in standard of living, increases in
longevity, decline in birthrate, growth of
comparative wealth, impact on status of
women, rise of socialism, impact of welfare
state, sociopolitical reactions/development
of sociopolitical philosophies
10.9
Impact of
overcrowding, challenge to meet
10.1, 10.3,
9.1, 9.3, 9.4,
Urbanization
housing/shelter needs, need to address waste
10.8, 10.9
9.5, 9.6, 9.8,
disposal/sanitation, ability to keep order,
ability to provide protection, availability of
jobs, ability to provide clean drinking water,
spread of disease, increased demand for
water, increased demand for energy sources,
loss of rural areas, loss of wilderness, loss
of forested areas, demand for transportation,
demand for infrastructure,
development/growth of squatter settlements,
impact on status of women, impact on
family structure, access to/demand for
education
9.9, 9.10
Impact of
secession, demand for a shift in the
10.2, 10.4,
Nationalism
boundaries, reaction to new boundaries,
10.5, 10.6,
citizenship/what does it mean to
10.7, 10.8,
belong/what does it mean not to belong,
force of unification, force of division,
development of national cohesion,
dissolution of national cohesion, lack of
national cohesion, emergence of separatism,
use of terrorism, manipulation of
nationalistic feelings/ultra-nationalism,
manipulation of belief systems to incite
conflict
10.9, 10.10
7
5/17/2017 DRAFT
This is a list of suggested Enduring Issues which is not intended to be memorized. It is
not meant to be an all-inclusive or comprehensive list.
Enduring Issue
Nested Issues
Grade 10
Key Idea
Connections
Grade 9
Key Idea
Connections
Impact of
challenge of securing resources, challenge
10.4, 10.5,
9.3, 9.5, 9.6,
Imperialism
of controlling land, challenge of
10.7, 10.8,
9.7, 9.8, 9.9,
Impact of
Colonization
Impact of Empire
Building
Impact of
Decolonization
maintaining control of territory, challenge
of exerting power, ability to supply people
living in controlled territories, ability to
protect citizens in controlled territories,
conflicting world views, maintaining
cultural identity, maintaining ethnic
identity, loss of cultural identity, loss of
ethnic identity, loss of traditions, challenges
to religious practices, loss of political
control, managing change, resistance,
response to resistance, resentment,
exploitation, segregation, discrimination,
disputes, conflict, threats to a culture as a
result of being conquered, improvements to
healthcare, introduction of new diseases,
improvements to infrastructure, loss of jobs,
debate over education, access to education,
ability to participate in/have a say in
government, economic overextension,
ability to get goods to market, market for
goods produced, challenges of moving away
from a barter economy
10.9, 10.10
9.10
Impact of
reaction to immigrants, reaction to migrants,
10.1, 10.3,
9.1, 9.3, 9.4,
Migration
reaction to outsiders/those who are
10.4, 10.5,
9.9, 9.10
different, challenge of integrating
10.7, 10.8,
immigrants, reaction to efforts to integrate
immigrants, reaction to refugees,
acceptance of refugees, problems faced by
refugees, disenfranchisement, strains on
housing, impact of squatter settlements,
strains on social welfare systems,
availability of jobs, access to citizenship,
debate over granting citizenship to
immigrants, economic costs of accepting
migrants, threats to or change to culture as a
result of accepting immigrants, economic
contributions of immigrants/migrants,
debate over economic benefits provided by
immigrants/migrants, benefit of cultural
contributions of immigrants/migrants,
impact of outmigration on homeland
10.9, 10.10
8
5/17/2017 DRAFT
This is a list of suggested Enduring Issues which is not intended to be memorized. It is
not meant to be an all-inclusive or comprehensive list.
Enduring Issue
Nested Issues
Grade 10
Key Idea
Connections
Grade 9
Key Idea
Connections
Impact of
rate of cultural change, unintended
10.1, 10.4,
9.10
Globalization
consequences of cultural change, costs of
10.5, 10.7,
cultural change, changes in people’s diets/
10.8, 10.9,
dress/housing/music, changes to traditional
culture, threats to traditional culture, threats
to language(s), access to information, access
to education, access to jobs/job
opportunities, threats or costs to
sustainability, debate over sustainability,
ability to maintain unique cultural traits,
support for cultural divergence, support for
cultural convergence, use of a common
language, displacement of
industries/companies, displacement of jobs,
impact on human capital, consequences of
interdependence, economic advantages,
economic risks, economic challenges,
effects of global debt crises, political
advantages, political risks, political
challenges, challenges of illegal trade,
debate over spread of technology, debate
over reduction in barriers, elimination of
inefficiencies, hostility toward
globalization, protests against globalization,
impact of migration, impact of cooperative
economic efforts, impact of cooperative
political efforts, impact of media, impact of
blended cultural ideas (music, language,
technology, healthcare), power of
transnational corporations, importance of
international workers, devaluation of
diversity, politics of diversity
10.10
Equity
lack of access to information, lack of access
10.1, 10.2,
9.1, 9.2, 9.3,
Issues/Lack of
to education, lack of access to food, lack of
10.3, 10.4,
9.7, 9.9, 9.10
Access
access to shelter, lack of access to clean
10.5, 10.6,
water, lack of access to jobs/occupations,
10.7, 10.8,
lack of access to a living wage, lack of
access to status, lack of access to power,
lack of access to health care/medical
treatment, lack of fairness, inequitable
treatment, rights not protected
10.9, 10.10
9
5/17/2017 DRAFT
This is a list of suggested Enduring Issues which is not intended to be memorized. It is
not meant to be an all-inclusive or comprehensive list.
Enduring Issue
Nested Issues
Grade 10
Key Idea
Connections
Grade 9
Key Idea
Connections
Impact of
consequences of cooperation on
10.2, 10.4,
Cooperation
countries/on cultures/on traditions,
10.5, 10.6,
(solving of mutual
consequences of mitigation of
10.7, 10.8,
problems)
hunger/famine, consequences of mitigation
of medical problems/health care issues,
consequences of disease prevention/efforts
to prevent the spread of disease,
consequences of mitigation of
environmental issues, consequences of
mitigation of climate change, consequences
of mitigation of pollution, consequences of
prevention of terrorism, consequences of
involvement in maintaining peace or in
multinational peacekeeping efforts,
consequences of mediating disputes,
consequences of membership in cooperative
organizations, benefits of working together
to solve mutual problems, challenges of
working together to solve mutual problems,
benefit of nongovernmental organizations,
challenges faced by nongovernmental
organizations
10.9, 10.10
10
